First Church Ministers
William Brinsmead 1666-1701
Robert Breck 1704-1731
Benjamin Kent 1733-1735
Aaron Smith 1740-1778
Asa Packard 1785-1806
Sylvester F. Bucklin 1808-1832
Charles Forbush 1833-1834
John N. Goodhue 1836-1839
George E. Day 1840-1847
David L. Ogden 1848-1850
Levi A. Field 1853-1859
George N. Anthony 1860-1869
Charles R. Treat 1870-1873
John Willard 1873-1879
Samuel E. Eastman 1880-1881
Albert F. Newton 1882-1892
William F. Stearns 1893-1895
Lincoln B. Goodrich 1896-1905
Albert H. Wheelock 1906-1916
Belvo Z. Stambaugh 1916-1920
Stanley H. Addison 1921-1928
Albert E. Beaumont 1928-1935
Alfred E. Wheeler 1942-1945
(Cummings was on active duty as a Navy Chaplin)
 Norman C. MacLean 1954-1961
 John W. Morrow 1961-1972
Zaven Dohanian 1973-1980
G. Jeffrey Marks, Assistant Pastor 1976-1976
Chester Dziczek, Assistant Pastor 1977-1977
Wayne N. Pruitt  1981-1993
Mary Aberg, Associate Pastor 1989-1992
Richard L. Weber 1993-2000
Gail H. Kendrick, Associate Pastor 1994-1998
Deborah Loomis Lafond 2002-2006
M. Elizabeth Waters, Revitalization Pastor  2006-2010
Kazimierz Bem 2011 –
 
Supply and Interim Pastors
Rev. George Denham, Supply Pastor 1850-1853
Rev. Dr. Horace F. Holton, Interim 1953-1954
Rev. Raymond Cosseboom , Supply Pastor 1961
Rev. Dr. Madison Scott, Interim Pastor 1972-1973
Rev. Dr. Glendon E. Bryce, Interim Pastor 1980-1981
Rev. Janet Parsons Mackey, Sabbatical Interim  1988
Rev. Dr. Gary Shahinian, Interim Associate pastor  1999-2000
Rev. Frederick Rhines, Intentional Interim Pastor 2000-2002
Rev. Jane Wenninger, Interim Associate Pastor  2000-2001
Rev. Gail Miller, Bridge Pastor 2006
Rev. Mary S. Poole, Bridge Pastor  2010-2011